Efficacy of axial TheraTogs on gait pattern in children with dyskinetic cerebral palsy: a randomized controlled trial

Abstract

Background

TheraTogs promotes proprioceptive sense of a child with cerebral palsy and improves abnormal muscle tone, posture alignment, balance, and gait. Therefore, the aim of this study was to investigate the efficacy of TheraTogs orthotic undergarment on gait pattern in children with dyskinetic cerebral palsy. Thirty children with dyskinetic cerebral palsy were selected for this randomized controlled study. They were randomly assigned to (1) an experimental group that received TheraTogs orthotic undergarment (12 h/day, 3 days/week) plus traditional physical therapy for 3 successive months and (2) a control group that received only traditional physical therapy program for the same time period. Gait parameters were measured at baseline and after 3 months of intervention using Pro-Reflex motion analysis.

Results

Children in both groups showed significant improvements in the gait parameters (P < 0.05), with significantly greater improvements in the experimental group than in the control group.

Conclusions

The use of TheraTogs may have a positive effect to improve gait pattern in children with dyskinetic cerebral palsy.

Trial registration

This trial was registered in the ClinicalTrial.gov PRS (NCT03037697).

Background

Cerebral palsy (CP) is a group of disorders of the development of movement and posture that occur as a result of a non-progressive lesion to the developing brain [1]. Children with CP usually have a variety of motor impairments, such as spasticity, involuntary movements, unsteady gait, and problems with balance that limit activities of daily living and self-care [2].

Dyskinetic cerebral palsy (DCP) is one of the most debilitating types of CP because it causes severe motor impairment [3]. Children with DCP experience abnormal muscle activity stemming from the simultaneous, sustained contraction of the agonist and antagonist muscles during movement [4, 5], resulting in difficulties maintaining spatiotemporal trajectories and considerable variability in their movements [6]. The most common manifestations are athetosis, chorea, and dystonia [7]. These involuntary movements can cause discomfort, interfere with voluntary movements, and limit or even impede upper and lower limb functions [8, 9].

Children with CP are often classified by severity of mobility limitation through the Gross Motor Function Classification System (GMFCS) [10]. This is a useful tool to identify levels of motor ability, guide treatment decisions, and allow estimation of the development of motor performance [11]. A common therapeutic goal for rehabilitation is to improve mobility and walking ability. Improved walking ability has a positive impact on achievement of daily activities and motivating social engagement [12].

Current intervention options, including physical and occupational therapies, pharmacological approaches, and deep brain stimulation, are often not successful or only partially successful in controlling symptoms. As a result, there is a need to investigate new non-invasive options for treating dyskinesia in children [13,14,15]. Physical therapy intervention is the major treatment for postural deviations in children with DCP. The designed exercise protocol is used to encourage adjustment and repositioning of skeletal segments which in turn produce static posture realignment. It has been reported that the exercise program is insufficient alone without additional physical therapy modalities to produce adaptive changes in postural control [16, 17].

TheraTogs orthotic undergarments have been developed to provide a gentle, passive force to correct alignment through the combination of a trunk-and-shorts system with a customized external strapping system. It is suggested that this system can improve joint stability, posture, and gait skills [18, 19]. The purpose of this study was to investigate efficacy of TheraTogs orthotics undergarments on gait pattern in children with DCP.

Methods

Design

This single-blind randomized controlled study was approved by the Ethical Committee of the Faculty of Applied Medical Sciences, Umm Al Qura University (19-MED-1-01-0004). Parents signed a consent form approving children participation. The children who participated in this study were enrolled from the physical therapy department, Maternity and Children Hospital, Makkah, Saudi Arabia. This trial was registered in the ClinicalTrial.gov PRS No NCT03037697.

Participants

Thirty children diagnosed with dyskinetic CP were recruited for this study. Their scores on the Gross Motor Function Classification System (GMFCS) were Levels I or II. The inclusion criteria for this study were age between 8 and 12 years; spasticity degree ranging between grades 1, 1+, and 2 according to the Modified Ashworth Scale (MAS); and the ability to understand and follow simple verbal instructions. The exclusion criteria were any fixed deformities that interfere with lower limb functions, cardiac or respiratory conditions that are affected by exercise, and the presence of seizures or lower limb orthopedic surgery in the preceding 12 months or botulinum toxin injections in the previous 6 months. During the study, children will not receive any treatment to improve the gait pattern other than the study intervention. They did not participate in any previous trials with orthotic undergarment, adhesive tape, or spiral strapping to the lower limbs and axial trunk.

Randomization

In order to eliminate bias in the treatment assignment, the children will be randomized into both groups. Randomization was performed utilizing the SPSS computer program (version 16; SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL). Assignment happened before the underlying appraisal. The control group received the traditional physical therapy program. The experimental group received TheraTogs orthotic undergarments in addition to the same traditional program given to the control group. The experimental design is shown as a flow diagram in Fig. 1.

Fig. 1

Flow chart showing the experimental design of the study

Gait parameters evaluation

All children were assessed for gait parameters before the treatment and at the end of 3 months of treatment by the same examiner using the Pro-Reflex motion analysis system (Qualisys; Qualisys Inc., Goeteborg, Sweden). This system consists of an 8-m-long wooden walkway, a three-dimensional infrared camera system with six cameras spaced equally on both sides of the walkway, and a personal computer with Q-Trace software installed to analyze the motion pattern. This system incorporates 9-mm-diameter reflective markers for optimizing the focus settings of the camera. Twelve markers were fixed bilaterally on the following landmarks: the superior border of the patella, laterally at the knee joint line, tibial tuberosity, lateral malleolus, heel posterior of the calcaneus, and between the second and third metatarsal heads. The procedures of calibration, capture, and analysis of data were performed according to guidelines in the manual of the motion system. The selected gait parameters were evaluated: velocity (m/s), stride length (m), cadence (steps/min), and percent of time spent in double limb support (%) [20, 21].

Interventions

Traditional physical therapy program

Children in both groups got the traditional physical therapy program, which included reflex-inhibiting exercises for both lower limbs, stretching exercises, strengthening exercises for muscles of the trunk and both lower limbs, proprioceptive training, balance exercises in all directions from a standing position using a wooden balance board, and gait training (1 h/day, 3 days/week for 3 consecutive months) [22].

TheraTogs orthotic application

Children in the experimental group received the strapping technique using TheraTogs orthotic undergarment strapping system (TheraTogs™ Inc., Telluride, USA). TheraTogs are made of a patented, proprietary, machine washable, compose fabric consisting of nylon and spandex with an inner foam that gently grips the skin and the underlying soft tissues and a velcro-sensitive outer layer to which therapist can affix elastic strapping, to effectively influence your patient’s movement, stability, posture, and gait. A TheraTogs orthotic undergarment consists of sleeveless tank-Top, two shorts (Hipster) each with two thigh cuffs and limb cuffs. All parts fabricated from nylon and spandex with a foam layer made of aqueous-based elastomeric urethane and a variety of elasticized straps. They are designed to be worn directly on the skin as undergarments that allow unimpeded toileting.

TheraTogs system gives the wearer a comfortable, breathable Latex-free “second skin” on his torso and thighs, providing vertical stiffness to reinforce postural stability and horizontal stretch for child compression and a comfortable fit. The following precautions will be considered when applying this strapping technique; the child should be comfortable without feeling constriction, itching, or circulatory impairment. The garments should be snug against the skin, with no significant gaps, folds, or loose material. Well-fit garments are snug enough that they effectively grip the wearer’s skin, without slipping. Each child will have his own TheraTogs orthotic undergarment, and it will not be allowed for any child to share his orthosis with others for several reasons: to avoid any infectious disease transformation, each child has its special size which may not fit with other, and the way of fitting and strapping technique will differ from one child to other according to his case.

The wearing schedule for this study was adopted and modified from Flanagan et al. [18]. Children wore TheraTogs orthotic undergarment and strapping system under their usual clothes so it was not annoying or disturbing. One week before starting the training program, the participating children wore their TheraTogs as preparatory stage without application of any exercise program with gradually increasing the worn time till reaching the 12 h per day, to allow the children to become acclimated to the system.

Statistical analysis

Comparison of assessments before and immediately after the treatment in each group (experimental or control) was performed using a paired t test. The comparison of assessments between both groups before and immediately after treatment was carried out using an unpaired t test. The Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS) version 16.00 was used for data analysis. P values less than 0.05 were considered to be statistically significant.

Results

Thirty children with DCP (18 boys and 12 girls) were included in this study. The children were randomly assigned to one of two equal-sized groups (n = 15 each). The demographic and clinical characteristics of the children were similar in both groups (Table 1).

Table 1 Demographical and clinical characteristics of the children at baseline

Baseline measurements revealed no significant differences in the mean values of gait parameters (velocity, stride length, cadence, and percent of time spent in double limb support) between the experimental and control groups (P > 0.05) (Table 2). However, there was a significant difference between the mean values of gait parameters obtained at the baseline and post-treatment assessments (P < 0.05). The children in the experimental group exhibited improvements in their gait parameters compared with children in the control group (Table 2).

Table 2 Pre and post-treatment mean values of gait parameters within each group and between groups

Discussion

The purpose of this study was to investigate the efficacy of the TheraTogs on gait pattern in children with DCP; comparison of the difference between the gait parameters was analyzed and compared between conditions with and without the TheraTogs. The results showed that the selected gait parameters of the children with DCP wearing the TheraTogs were significantly improved compared to those who did not wear the TheraTogs.

Cerebral palsy causes nervous system injury and results in lower limb spasticity, contracture, lack of coordination, muscle weakness, and inability to move independently in children [23, 24]. When comparing the number of motor units recruited during a voluntary contraction, the children with CP had less units than the healthy children [25]. Along with muscular spasm and joint contracture, the problems cause abnormal gait, joint restriction, and loss of functional activity [26]. Ambulation is an important functional activity, as a previous study of Kadhim and Miller [26] pointed out that 90% of children with CP had instability problems during gait, and 54% of the children were unable to walk alone. Therefore, the children with CP needed more training and assistance for walking in the rehabilitation treatment.

TheraTogs is certainly a viable and useful physical therapy intervention tool for modulating biomechanical malalignment and poor postural control in children having CP. Many scientists proposed that therapeutic strapping would provide the foundation for increasing proprioceptive and tactile awareness, restoring optimal muscle length to provide a basis for normal firing and recruitment patterns and orienting the muscle force along normal vectors in the frontal and sagittal planes [27,28,29,30].

TheraTogs and strapping system are designed to improve body awareness, postural stability, and functional joint alignment during therapy as well as during performance of activities of daily living. Many authors supported that lower extremity strapping by application of TheraTogs and strapping system could (1) gently rotate the thigh as needed to improve knee joint alignment and function and also to improve the recruitment of muscles that cross the hip joint in swing phase, (2) gently rotate the leg as needed to improve foot alignment and function, (3) reduce hip adduction and keep the legs apart to correct scissoring gait, and (4) reduce trunk, hip, and knee flexion [19, 31,32,33].

The findings of this study agree with that of El Fiky et al. [29]; they revealed that using of TheraTogs for a long period might act as a continuous reflex-inhibiting pattern for the abnormal internal rotation and adducted hip pattern of the involved spastic limb. This inhibitory mechanism might help in dampening the continuing reciprocal inhibiting pattern of these overexcited groups on the antagonist groups facilitating their action [29].

The study by Chang et al. [34] aimed to evaluate the effects of external strap orthosis on plantar pressure and gait parameters in children with CP. They found that the plantar pressure and spatiotemporal gait analysis indicated the potential use of external strap orthosis to improve the gait speed, stride length, and cadence and influence the foot motion and path of pressure trajectory in the children with CP. The elastic force of the orthosis can provide immediate assistance to correct the leg alignment and improve the gait performance. The current results support the importance of applying a customized external strap orthosis for the child in the treadmill ambulation training [34].

The results of the present study are consistent with those of Jung et al.’s [35]; they showed that the spatiotemporal gait variables of the children with CP wearing the TheraTogs were significantly improved compare to those who did not wear the TheraTogs. The results can suggest that the use of TheraTogs in children with CP may have positive effect to improve the gait ability [35].

Abd El-Kafy studied the clinical impact of ground reaction orthoses and TheraTogs in gait parameters of children with spastic diplegia CP. The results of the study showed that the use of TheraTogs and the ground reaction orthoses during treatment of children with CP over 12 weeks led to a greater improvement in their gait than using conventional treatment without TheraTogs [36].

However, this study has some limitations, namely, (1) the small sample size does not allow the generalization of the results, (2) the lack of participants with other diagnosed types of CP, (3) the long-term effect was not be investigated, (4) the effect of the physical therapy program in both groups also limits the ability to isolate the contribution of the TheraTogs orthotic undergarment alone. The results of the present study are encouraging, but further studies that include a larger number of children with CP would provide results that could be more easily generalized. Long-term effects of the orthosis on functional activity also needed to be investigated. Future studies investigating the effect of TheraTogs orthotic undergarment and its role in improving muscle strength and energy expenditure in children with CP may be useful for guiding clinical practice.

Conclusion

The results of the present study showed that the gait pattern of the children with DCP wearing the TheraTogs was significantly improved compared to those who did not wear the TheraTogs. The results can suggest that the use of TheraTogs may have positive effect to improve the gait pattern in children with DCP.